A good scorecard turns “that call felt off” into something a rep can fix tomorrow. A bad one turns coaching into an argument. Here’s how to build one that works on a phone sales floor with setters and closers.
Start with two scorecards, not one
Setters and closers have different jobs, so grading them on the same sheet punishes both. A setter’s job is to qualify and book an appointment that actually sits. A closer’s job is to understand the problem, present the fix and get a decision. Give each role its own scorecard.
Pick five to seven categories
More than seven and nobody remembers them. Fewer than five and the score hides too much. For most floors, these are a good starting point:
Setter scorecard
- Opening. Introduces themselves and the reason for the call within the first 15 seconds.
- Qualification. Confirms the questions that decide whether the appointment is worth booking.
- Decision-makers. Finds out who else needs to be on the call, and invites them.
- Booking. Offers specific times instead of asking “when works for you?”
- Confirmation. Repeats the time and sets expectations for what happens next.
Closer scorecard
- Discovery. Asks enough questions to restate the customer’s problem in their own words.
- Value before price. Ties the offer to that problem before any number comes up.
- Compliance. Reads required disclosures, in the right order.
- Objections. Handles concerns instead of skipping past them or applying pressure.
- Close or next step. Ends with a decision or a booked follow-up, never “call us back.”
Weight what actually moves revenue
Not every category is equal. If your floor loses most deals at the price, weight “value before price” higher. Compliance often works best as a pass or fail gate: a perfect call that skips a required disclosure shouldn’t score 95.
Write criteria a stranger could grade
“Good rapport” means something different to every manager. “Uses the customer’s name and asks one question about their situation before pitching” doesn’t. If two managers grade the same call and land more than ten points apart, the wording is too vague.
Test it on calls you already know
Pull ten calls: a few great ones, a few that went badly and a few in between. Grade them with the new scorecard. If the great calls don’t score highest, the scorecard is measuring the wrong things. Adjust and test again.
Then score every call, not a sample
A scorecard only coaches the calls someone hears. Most QA teams can hear a small slice of what the floor makes in a week. That’s the gap AI call scoring closes: the same scorecard, applied to every recorded call, with a note to the rep right after.
See it on one of your calls.
Send a recorded call and get a free scorecard within one business day.
